Her most recognizable recurring character was Jan Brady which she also played on stage. She also did celebrity impressions of Tori Spelling and Tonya Harding. She starred in the movies The Thin Pink Line in 1998 and Can’t Stop Dancing in 1999. Hutsell quit acting to raise her daughter but returned in 2009 when she starred in the movie He’s Such a Girl. She went on to star in the movies Bridesmaids and Grown Ups 2 and has also appeared in episodes of the TV series Pretty the Series and Suburgatory.