In 2014 she starred as Fabienne on the series Mixology. In 2015 Shaw starred as Shayla Nico on the television series Mr. Robot and in 2016 she starred as Naomi on the TV series Good Girls Revolt. She won a Sundance Film Festival Short Film Jury Prize in 2015 for SMILF. Shaw has also starred in several other films including Just Like the Son, Explicit Ills, Falling Up, The Freebie, The End of Love, Knife Fight, The Pretty One, Lullaby, Someone Marry Barry, Joshy, Dreamland, Stronger, and more.